Social Europe

politics, economy and employment & labour

  • Themes
    • European digital sphere
    • Recovery and resilience
  • Publications
    • Books
    • Dossiers
    • Occasional Papers
    • Research Essays
    • Brexit Paper Series
  • Podcast
  • Videos
  • Newsletter

Minimum-wages directive: it’s legal

Susanne Wixforth and Lukas Hochscheidt 8th April 2021

Last October, the European Commission proposed a framework directive on minimum wages. Whether one likes it or not, the EU is competent to do so.

minimum wages directive,directive on minimum wages
Susanne Wixforth

From the beginning of her mandate, the president of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, promised to ‘put forward a framework to ensure that every worker in our Union has a fair minimum wage’. Proposing in October 2020 a directive ‘on adequate minimum wages in the European Union’, the commission kept this promise.

By no means does the commission envisage a uniform statutory minimum wage for the EU. Rather, the directive would establish prerequisites for national minimum wages. To avoid interference with collective bargaining and wage-setting by social partners, the directive would also protect and promote collectively-agreed minimum wages. This is indeed crucial: for many years the share of workers covered by collective agreements in Europe has been declining.

minimum wages directive,directive on minimum wages
Lukas Hochscheidt

The heated debate the proposal has occasioned has little however to do with the protection of collective agreements—what led to controversy are the proposed minimum thresholds for statutory minimum wages in the member states. Critics argue that the EU is simply not competent to legislate on a binding framework for national minimum wages. Referring to article 153(5) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU (TFEU), which excludes ‘pay’ from EU competences, they claim that the framework falls outwith the treaties.

Subsidiary and proportionate

The legal basis of the commission’s proposal is article 153(1)b TFEU, which grants the EU a supporting and complementing role in the shaping of working conditions in the member states. EU measures in this domain have to meet two conditions: they must be subsidiary, not intervening in issues member states would be able to deal with themselves, and proportionate, intervening only as much as necessary and as little as possible.

Our job is keeping you informed!


Subscribe to our free newsletter and stay up to date with the latest Social Europe content.


We will never send you spam and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Thank you!

Please check your inbox and click on the link in the confirmation email to complete your newsletter subscription.

.

The framework for minimum wages complies with both: it is subsidiary because member states remain fully responsible for setting and shaping their own minimum wages and it is proportionate because not all minimum wages in Europe protect workers from in-work poverty (see chart). Moreover, the single market dearly needs a level playing-field for wages. Hence, European action is necessary and appropriate to fulfil the overarching goals of the EU.

minimum wages directive,directive on minimum wages
Source: M Lübker and T Schulten, WSI-Mindestlohnbericht 2021, Wirtschafts- und Sozialwissenschaftliches Institut der Hans-Böckler-Stiftung, Düsseldorf

Critics point to tension between articles 153(1)b and 153(5). But this is no obstacle to the commission’s proposal. There are a number of reasons why lack of competence for direct wage determination (article 153(5)) does not obstruct a framework directive on adequate minimum wages.

Indirect action

First, the fact that the EU must not directly set wages does not prevent indirect action: article 153(5) only excludes from EU competence measures that immediately affect wages. The commission aims to create a framework which brings national minimum wages to an adequate level as measured by the respective median or average wages in the member states.

Secondly, there are several examples of such indirect effects of EU legislation on wage-setting: regulations on maternity protection, paid leave and the posting of workers also intervene indirectly in the wage-setting process. The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has already confirmed the legitimacy of these measures—for the EU to be able to harmonise social and labour-market policies (as provided for in the treaties), the exceptions laid down in article 153(5) must be interpreted narrowly. Otherwise, the EU could not exercise its competences in the arena of working conditions (as provided for in article 153(1)b). Thus, the exemption made for direct wage-setting must not impede the effectiveness of other measures tackling discrimination or in-work poverty.

Thirdly, promotion of decent working conditions and living wages is an objective of the EU rooted in the treaties. Article 3 of the Treaty on European Union and article 8 of the TFEU oblige the union to combat social exclusion and inequalities. Article 151 TFEU meanwhile acknowledges, as binding EU commitments, the objectives of the European Social Charter of the Council of Europe and the Community Charter of the Fundamental Social Rights of Workers.


We need your support


Social Europe is an independent publisher and we believe in freely available content. For this model to be sustainable, however, we depend on the solidarity of our readers. Become a Social Europe member for less than 5 Euro per month and help us produce more articles, podcasts and videos. Thank you very much for your support!

Become a Social Europe Member

Finally, the framework for minimum wages is also relevant to the functioning of the single market. Regarding cross-border employment, the ECJ has already affirmed that prevention of competitive advantage through wage divergence is a legitimate objective of EU legislation. The EU must not however limit this approach to cross-border activities: wage divergence creates competitive advantages regardless of whether work is performed across borders or inside member states.

The directive on adequate minimum wages would make an important contribution in this regard as it would effectively level the playing-field for wages—thus protecting precarious workers from discrimination. The fight against discrimination on the labour market is one of the key motivations of social and labour-market harmonisation by the EU. The ECJ, too, has been very keen to enforce EU anti-discrimination law in its decisions.

No objection

The treaties, existing secondary legislation and the jurisprudence of the ECJ thus offer no objection to a framework for adequate minimum wages based on artcle 153(1)b TFEU. This legal assessment was confirmed by the Legal Service of the Council of the EU on March 9th.

The framework directive would contribute to the fight against social exclusion, promote living wages and tackle discrimination against precarious workers. It would moreover favour wage equality between men and women (article 157(1) TFEU), level the playing field for wages and make the single market fairer for both firms and workers.

This article is based on a legal opinion by Prof Eberhard Eichenhofer, commissioned by the German Confederation of Trade Unions

Susanne Wixforth and Lukas Hochscheidt

Susanne Wixforth is head of unit in the Europe and International Department of the German Trade Union Confederation (DGB). Lukas Hochscheidt is a research assistant there.

Home ・ Economy ・ Minimum-wages directive: it’s legal

Most Popular Posts

schools,Sweden,Swedish,voucher,choice Sweden’s schools: Milton Friedman’s wet dreamLisa Pelling
world order,Russia,China,Europe,United States,US The coming world orderMarc Saxer
south working,remote work ‘South working’: the future of remote workAntonio Aloisi and Luisa Corazza
Russia,Putin,assets,oligarchs Seizing the assets of Russian oligarchsBranko Milanovic
Russians,support,war,Ukraine Why do Russians support the war against Ukraine?Svetlana Erpyleva

Most Recent Posts

Sakharov,nuclear,Khrushchev Unhappy birthday, Andrei SakharovNina L Khrushcheva
Gazprom,Putin,Nordstream,Putin,Schröder How the public loses out when politicians cash inKatharina Pistor
defence,europe,spending Ukraine and Europe’s defence spendingValerio Alfonso Bruno and Adriano Cozzolino
North Atlantic Treaty Organization,NATO,Ukraine The Ukraine war and NATO’s renewed credibilityPaul Rogers
transnational list,European constituency,European elections,European public sphere A European constituency for a European public sphereDomènec Ruiz Devesa

Other Social Europe Publications

The transatlantic relationship
Women and the coronavirus crisis
RE No. 12: Why No Economic Democracy in Sweden?
US election 2020
Corporate taxation in a globalised era

Hans Böckler Stiftung Advertisement

Towards a new Minimum Wage Policy in Germany and Europe: WSI minimum wage report 2022

The past year has seen a much higher political profile for the issue of minimum wages, not only in Germany, which has seen fresh initiatives to tackle low pay, but also in those many other countries in Europe that have embarked on substantial and sustained increases in statutory minimum wages. One key benchmark in determining what should count as an adequate minimum wage is the threshold of 60 per cent of the median wage, a ratio that has also played a role in the European Commission's proposals for an EU-level policy on minimum wages. This year's WSI Minimum Wage Report highlights the feasibility of achieving minimum wages that meet this criterion, given the political will. And with an increase to 12 euro per hour planned for autumn 2022, Germany might now find itself promoted from laggard to minimum-wage trailblazer.


FREE DOWNLOAD

ETUI advertisement

Bilan social / Social policy in the EU: state of play 2021 and perspectives

The new edition of the Bilan social 2021, co-produced by the European Social Observatory (OSE) and the European Trade Union Institute (ETUI), reveals that while EU social policy-making took a blow in 2020, 2021 was guided by the re-emerging social aspirations of the European Commission and the launch of several important initiatives. Against the background of Covid-19, climate change and the debate on the future of Europe, the French presidency of the Council of the EU and the von der Leyen commission must now be closely scrutinised by EU citizens and social stakeholders.


AVAILABLE HERE

Eurofound advertisement

Living and working in Europe 2021

The Covid-19 pandemic continued to be a defining force in 2021, and Eurofound continued its work of examining and recording the many and diverse impacts across the EU. Living and working in Europe 2021 provides a snapshot of the changes to employment, work and living conditions in Europe. It also summarises the agency’s findings on issues such as gender equality in employment, wealth inequality and labour shortages. These will have a significant bearing on recovery from the pandemic, resilience in the face of the war in Ukraine and a successful transition to a green and digital future.


AVAILABLE HERE

Foundation for European Progressive Studies Advertisement

EU Care Atlas: a new interactive data map showing how care deficits affect the gender earnings gap in the EU

Browse through the EU Care Atlas, a new interactive data map to help uncover what the statistics are often hiding: how care deficits directly feed into the gender earnings gap.

While attention is often focused on the gender pay gap (13%), the EU Care Atlas brings to light the more worrisome and complex picture of women’s economic inequalities. The pay gap is just one of three main elements that explain the overall earnings gap, which is estimated at 36.7%. The EU Care Atlas illustrates the urgent need to look beyond the pay gap and understand the interplay between the overall earnings gap and care imbalances.


BROWSE THROUGH THE MAP

About Social Europe

Our Mission

Article Submission

Membership

Advertisements

Legal Disclosure

Privacy Policy

Copyright

Social Europe ISSN 2628-7641

Social Europe Archives

Search Social Europe

Themes Archive

Politics Archive

Economy Archive

Society Archive

Ecology Archive

Follow us on social media

Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter

Follow us on LinkedIn

Follow us on YouTube